This game should stay under the total. The Guardians have had trouble scoring runs against this Yankees team on the road and it was evident in game 1. Bibee has pitched much better on the road this season so he and their bullpen are going to check a lot of offense. His only start against them this season saw the game stay under the total. Cole has an ERA of 1.94 in his last three starts so he is going to make it tough for the Guardians to hit him up. Two of his three starts versus Cleveland this season went under the total. This is playoff baseball so expect runs to be at a premium.

Best bet: take the Under the Total.